Free will is an illusion. The illusion
itself is the foundation of our society, and the foundation which allows us to
carry on as individuals. Society is founded upon the presupposition that we
have free will, and even goes out of its way to defend that; acknowledging, for
example, situations in which our actions are not under our control, be it
influenced chemically through some form of intoxication, or a more general
mental disorder, giving rise to leniency when laws are broken under these
situations. Maybe a punishment is less severe. Maybe insanity is pleaded,
leading to incarceration in a mental institution.
This underlying presumption
of free will is the bedrock of what you could call the overall aim of
civilisation: to thrive. To thrive, we need laws and societal constructs to
guide our actions. To control us. Evolving over time, these have, and still
are, morphed into more and more ideal conditions under which to thrive (in
general, and heinous acts notwithstanding). Without this presupposition, there
could be no responsibility, and no repercussions for actions. Where situations
like this have evolved in the past, anarchy has eventually resolved itself back
into order. We can take this macro example and apply it to ourselves. Being a
Materialist, I therefore lean towards Determinism. Determinism is problematic
because it would mean that we are ultimately not responsible for our own
actions, yet it is a necessary component of society that we are, and so this
innate illusion, self-imposed, of free will, has evolved in us too. Everything
has causal reason, from the physical elements of our bodily functions; the need
to breathe and eat and sleep: to the traits we develop that govern our actions.
Our likes and dislikes, and so forth. There is a biological impetus that pushes
us forward; it’s more obviously seen and felt with physical manifestations of
hunger and sex drive, but it can also be something small we pick up on the way,
such as a liking for a particular song, perhaps something we associate with a positive
feeling in childhood, leading to a liking for a particular genre of music,
which we listen to because we enjoy it. Is this free will? What music we like?
Strictly speaking, no. But we treat it as if it were, because that is how you
go on living. Just like society, in a self-imposed delusion. Even now, if this
is true and here I am, completely aware of this, has it affected what I’m
writing? Will it affect what I do next? Will I implode? No. So does it really
matter if we think we have free will or not?
grt
ReplyDelete